Skip to main content
Intended for healthcare professionals
Skip to main content
Restricted access
Research article
First published online April 20, 2017

‘The line between intervention and abuse’ – autism and applied behaviour analysis

Abstract

This article outlines the emergence of ABA (Applied Behaviour Analysis) in the mid-20th century, and the current popularity of ABA in the anglophone world. I draw on the work of earlier historians to highlight the role of Ole Ivar Lovaas, the most influential practitioner of ABA. I argue that reception of his initial work was mainly positive, despite concerns regarding its efficacy and use of physical aversives. Lovaas’ work, however, was only cautiously accepted by medical practitioners until he published results in 1987. Many accepted the results as validation of Lovaas’ research, though both his methods and broader understanding of autism had shifted considerably since his early work in the 1960s. The article analyses the controversies surrounding ABA since the early 1990s, considering in particular criticisms made by autistic people in the ‘neurodiversity movement’. As with earlier critics, some condemn the use of painful aversives, exemplified in the campaign against the use of shock therapy at the Judge Rotenberg Center. Unlike earlier, non-autistic critics, however, many in this movement reject the ideological goals of ABA, considering autism a harmless neurological difference rather than a pathology. They argue that eliminating benign autistic behaviour through ABA is impermissible, owing to the individual psychological harm and the wider societal impact. Finally, I compare the claims made by the neurodiversity movement with those made by similar 20th- and 21st-century social movements.

Get full access to this article

View all access and purchase options for this article.

References

Allure A. (2014) ‘Parents of Autistic Children Fight for Treatment in an Unforgiving Market’, The Guardian [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.theguardian.com/money/2014/apr/21/autism-children-parents-therapy-insurance-treatment
ASAN (n.d. (a)) ‘Our History’ [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://autisticadvocacy.org/home/about-asan/our-history/
ASAN (n.d. (b)) Position Statements, ASAN Website [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://autisticadvocacy.org/policy-advocacy/position-statements/
‘Author Unknown’ (1965) ‘Screams, Slaps and Love: A Surprising, Shocking Treatment Helps Far-gone Mental Cripples’, Life [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://neurodiversity.com/library_screams_1965.html
Autism (n.d.) ABA (PRT method) for autism [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.autism.net.au/Autism_ABA.htm
Autism Friends Network (2013) AFN Goals and Aims [online], accessed 22 March 2017, accessible at: http://autismfriendsnetwork.biz/portal.php
Autism Mythbusters (n.d) The Truth About ABA [online], accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: http://autismmythbusters.com/parents/therapy/the-truth-about-aba/
Autism Speaks (n.d.) Applied Behaviour Analysis [online], Accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: https://www.autismspeaks.org/what-autism/treatment/applied-behavior-analysis-aba
Autism Truths (n.d.) Summary of Treatments for Autism [online], accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: http://www.autismtruths.org/index.php?p=SummaryofTreatmentsforAutismRamKairamMD
Ayllon T., Michael J. (1959) ‘The Psychiatric Nurse as a Behavioural Engineer’, Journal of Experimental Analysis of Behaviour 2: 323–34.
Bascom J. (2012) ‘Quiet Hands’, in Bascom J. (ed.) Loud Hands: Autistic People, Speaking. Washington, DC: the Autistic Press, pp. 177–83.
Benyon L. (2014) ‘How a Controversial Therapy Has Changed my Autistic Daughter’s Life’, The Express [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.express.co.uk/life-style/life/490359/applied-behaviour-analysis-helped-daughters-autism
Bettelheim B. (1967) The Empty Fortress. London: Free Press.
Blackman L. (2001) Hearing Voices: Embodiment and Experience. London: Free Association.
Boden M. A. (2006) Mind as Machine: A History of Cognitive Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Broadstock M., Doughty C., Eggleston M. (2007) ‘Systematic Review of the Effectiveness of Pharmacological Treatments for Adolescents and Adults with Autism Spectrum Disorder’, Autism 11(4): 335–48.
Buchanan R. (2010) Playing with Fire: The Controversial History of Hans Eysenck. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Burkaba C. (n.d.) History [online], accessed 21 January 2016, accessible at: http://www.christinaburkaba.com/History.htm
Campbell P. (2005) ‘From Little Acorns: The Mental Health Service User Movement’, in Bell A., Lindley P. (eds) Beyond the Water Towers. London: Sainsbury Centre for Mental Health; available online, accessed 17 May 2016, accessible at: http://studymore.org.uk/pcacorns.pdf
Charlton J. (2000) Nothing About Us Without Us. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Dawson M. (n.d.) ‘The Misbehaviour of Behaviourists – Ethical Challenges to the Autism-ABA Industry’, [online] accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.sentex.net/∼nexus23/naa_aba.html
Dawson M. (2003) ‘Bettelheim’s Worst Crime: Autism and the Epidemic of Responsibility’, [online], accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: http://www.sentex.net/∼nexus23/md_01.html
Dellar R., Curtis T., Leslie E., eds (2000) Mad Pride: A Celebration of Mad Culture. London: Chipmunk Publishing.
DeMyer M. K., Barton S., Alpern G. D., et al. (1974) ‘The Measured Intelligence of Autistic Children’, Journal of Autism and Childhood Schizophrenia 4(1):42–60.
Dixon D., Vogel T., Tarbox J. (2012) ‘A Brief History of Functional Analysis and Applied Behaviour Analysis’, in Matson J. L. (ed.) Functional Assessment For Challenging Behaviors. Autism and Child Psychopathology series. New York and London: Springer. (Springer science and business media) DOI 10.1007/978-1-4614-3037-7_2.
Dolnick E. (1998) Madness on the Couch: Blaming the Victim in the Heyday of Psychoanalysis. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Donnellan A. (1988) Progress without Punishment. New York: Teachers College Press.
Donvan J., Zucker C. (2016) In a Different Key: The Story of Autism. London: Allen Lane.
Epstein S. (1998) Impure Science: AIDS, Activism, and the Politics of Knowledge. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Evans B. (2013) ‘How Autism Became Autism’, History of the Human Sciences 26(3): 3–31.
Evans B. (2014) ‘The Foundations of Autism’, Bulletin of the History of Medicine 88(2): 253–85.
Eyal G. (2010) The Autism Matrix. Cambridge: Polity Press.
Eysenck H. J., Rachman J. (1965) The Causes and Cures of Neurosis. San Diego, CA: R. R. Knapp.
Faderman L. (2015) The Gay Revolution. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Feinstein A. (2011) A History of Autism: Conversations with the Pioneers. Oxford: Wiley.
Ferster C. (1961) ‘Positive Reinforcement and Behavioural Deficits of Autistic Children’, Child Development 32: 437–56.
Freudenheim M. (2004) ‘Battling Insurers over Autism Treatment’, The New York Times [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/12/21/business/battling-insurers-over-autism-treatment.html
Fromm-Reichman F. (1948) ‘Notes on the Development of Treatment of Schizophrenics by Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy’, Psychiatry 11: 263–73.
Fuller P. R. (1949) ‘Operant Conditioning of a Vegetative Human Organism’, The American Journal of Psychology 62: 578–90.
Gardner H. (1987) The Mind’s New Science. New York: Basic Books.
Gardner H. (2000) Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelligences for the 21st Century. New York: Basic Books.
Grandin T. (1986) Emergence: Labelled Autistic. New York: Grand Central Publishing.
Hacking I. (1991) ‘The Making and Molding of Child Abuse’, Critical Inquiry 17(2): 253–88.
Hacking I. (1999) The Social Construction of What? Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Hacking I. (2013) ‘Making Up Autism’ [podcast], audio accessed 17 May 2016, accessible at: http://www.bshs.org.uk/podcast-professor-ian-hacking-making-up-autism
Harmon A. (2004) ‘How About Not Curing Us, Some Autistics are Pleading’, New York Times [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/12/20/health/how-about-not-curing-us-some-autistics-are-pleading.html
Hastings R. (2013) ‘Autism and Evidence 5:15 Criticisms of ABA and Some Responses’, [online], accessed 21 January 2016, accessible at: http://profhastings.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/autism-and-evidence-5-15-criticisms-of.html
Hearing Voices Network (2016) accessed 4 November 2016, accessible at: http://www.hearing-voices.org/
Horwitz A. (2013) Anxiety: A Short History. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Howlin P. (2005) ‘The Effectiveness of Interventions for Children with Autism’, J Nueral Transm Suppl. 69: 101–19.
Howlin P., Rutter M. (1989) Treatment of Autistic Children. Chichester, Sx: Wiley.
Jordon R. (2001) ‘Book Reviews: Parents’ Education as Autism Therapists: Applied Behaviour Analysis in Context by M. Keenan et al.’, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 42(2): 421–3.
Kapp S. (2013) ‘Deficit, Difference or Both? Autism and Neurodiversity’, Developmental Psychology 49(1): 59–71.
Lambert C. (2013) ‘Is it Right to Try to Normalise Autism?’, The Guardian [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.theguardian.com/education/2013/oct/29/specialeducationneeds-autism
Lee S., et al. (2011) ‘Massage Therapy for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders: A Systematic Review’, The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 72(3): 406–11, [online] accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.psychiatrist.com/JCP/article/Pages/2011/v72n03/v72n0318.aspx
Living with Schizophrenia (2017) Schizophrenia and Language [online], accessed 10 March 2017, accessible at: https://www.livingwithschizophreniauk.org/advice-sheets/schizophrenia-and-language/#
Lovaas O. I. (1966) ‘Establishment of Social Reinforcers in Two Schizophrenic Children on the Basis of Food’, Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 4(4): 109–225.
Lovaas O. I (1974) interviewed by Paul Chance, Psychology Today 7 (January); accessed 8 August 2016, accessible at: “http://neurodiversity.com/library_chance_1974.html
Lovaas O. I. (1987) ‘Behavioural Treatment and Normal Educational and Intellectual Functioning in Young Autistic Children’, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 55(1): 3–9.
Marino L., Lilienfled S. (2007) ‘Dolphin Assisted Therapy: More Flawed Data and More Flawed Conclusions’, Anthrozoos 20(3): 239–49 [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.psychiatrist.com/JCP/article/Pages/2011/v72n03/v72n0318.aspx
Marks S. (2015) ‘Psychologists as Therapists: The Development of Behavioural Traditions’, in Hall J., Pilgrim D., Turpin G. (eds) Clinical Psychology in Britain: Historical Perspectives. Leicester: BPS Books, pp. 194–207.
Matson J., Neal D. (2012) ‘History and Overview’, in Matson J. (ed.) Applied Behaviour Analysis for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders. New York: Springer, pp. 1–15.
Maurice C. (1994) Let Me Hear Your Voice: A Family’s Triumph Over Autism, 2nd edn. New York: Ballantine Books.
McPhilemy C., Dillenburger K. (2013) ‘Parents’ Experiences of Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA)- Based Interventions for Children Diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder’, British Journal of Special Education 40(4): 154–61.
Mudford O., et al. (2001) ‘Parent-management Behavioural Treatment for Pre-school Children with Autism: Some Characteristics of UK Programs’, Research in Developmental Disabilities 22: 173–82.
Murray S. (2012) Autism. Oxford: Routledge.
Nadesan M. (2005) Constructing Autism. Oxford: Routledge.
NAS (n.d.) NAS Website, [online], accessed 21 January 2016, accessible at: http://www.autism.org.uk/get-involved/media-centre/position-statements/interventions.aspx
Neumeier (2012) ‘Inhumane Beyond all Reason: The Torture of Autistics and Other People With Disabilities at the Judge Rotenberg Centre’, in Bascom J. (ed.) Loud Hands: Autistic People, Speaking. Washington, DC: the Autistic Press, pp. 204–23.
Oberman L., Rotenberg A., Pascual-Leone A. (2015) ‘Use of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation in Autism Spectrum Disorders’, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 45(2): 524–36.
Olsson M., et al. (2015) ‘“Recovery” From the Diagnosis of Autism – and Then?”’, Neuropsychiatry. Dis. Treat. 7(11): 999–1005.
Ospina M., et al. (2008) ‘Behavioural and Developmental Interventions for Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Clinical Systematic Review, PLoS ONE 3: 11, [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0003755
Risley T. (1968) ‘The Effects and Side-effects of Punishing the Autistic Behaviours of a Deviant Child’, Journal of Applied Behavioural Analysis 1: 21–34.
Rutter M. (1972) ‘Childhood Schizophrenia Reconsidered’, Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 2: 315–37.
Saks E. (2012) ‘Elyn Saks: A Tale of Mental Illness – From the Inside [video], accessed 17 May 2016, accessible at: https://www.ted.com/talks/elyn_saks_seeing_mental_illness?language=en
Sequenzia A. (2015) ‘My Thoughts on ABA’, Autism Womens Network [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://autismwomensnetwork.org/my-thoughts-on-aba/
Shapiro J. (1993) No Pity. New York: Three Rivers Press.
Silberman S. (2015) Neurotribes. London: Allen & Unwin.
Silverman C. (2012) Understanding Autism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Sinclair J. (2005) ‘Autism Network International: The Development of a Community and its Culture, ANI Website [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.autismnetworkinternational.org/History_of_ANI.html,
Skinner B. F. (1938) The Behavior of Organisms: An Experimental Analysis. New York: Appleton-Century.
Smith R. (1997) The Fontana History of the Human Sciences. London: Fontana Press.
Smith R. (2013) Between Mind and Nature: A History of Psychology. London: Reaktion Books.
Socially Anxious Advocate (2015) ‘Why I Left ABA’, [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: https://sociallyanxiousadvocate.wordpress.com/2015/05/22/why-i-left-aba/
Spinney L. (2007) ‘Therapy for Autistic Children Causes Outcry in France’, The Lancet 370(09588): 645–6.
Staub M. (2011) Madness is Civilization: When the Diagnosis was Social, 1948–1980. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Szalavaitz M. (2011) ‘The Sissy-boy Experiment: Why Gender-related Cases Call for Scientists’ Humility’, Time [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://healthland.time.com/2011/06/08/the-sissy-boy-experiment-why-gender-related-cases-call-for-scientists-humility
Timimi S., Gardner N., McCabe B. (2011) The Myth of Autism. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
USCB (n.d.) Celebrity Events [online], accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: http://education.ucsb.edu/autism/celebrity-events
Vivian A. (2012) ‘They Hate You. Yes, You’, in Bascom J. (ed.) Loud Hands: Autistic People, Speaking. Washington, DC: the Autistic Press, pp. 183–9.
Waltz M. (2013) Autism: A Social and Medical History. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Weiss M. J. (2006) ‘The Relationship between Early Learning Rates and Treatment Outcome for Children with Autism Receiving Intensive Home-based Applied Behaviour Analysis’, The Behaviour Analyst Today 7(1): 96–110.
Werner D. (1997) Nothing About Us Without Us. Palo Alto, CA: Healthwrights.
Willingham E. (2012) ‘No Evidence Supporting Chelation As Autism Treatment’, Forbes [online], accessed 21 October 2015, accessible at: http://www.forbes.com/sites/emilywillingham/2012/11/30/no-evidence-supporting-chelation-as-autism-treatment/,
Wing L., Potter D. (2002) ‘The Epidemiology of Autistic Spectrum Disorders: Is the Prevalence Rising?’, Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews 8(3): 151–61.
Woods A. (2013) ‘The Voice Hearer’, Journal of Mental Health 22(3): 263–70.
Yule W. (2015) Personal communication with the author (1 October).
Zurcher A. (2012) ‘Tackling that Troublesome Issue of ABA and Ethics’, Emma’s Hope Book [online], accessed 27 January 2015, accessible at: http://emmashopebook.com/2012/10/10/tackling-that-troublesome-issue-of-aba-and-ethics/

Biographies

Patrick Kirkham holds an MPhil in the History, Philosophy and Sociology of Science, Technology and Medicine from the University of Cambridge, where his dissertation focused on the history of the neurodiversity movement. He also holds a BA in Natural Sciences. Patrick works as a policy advisor in the civil service and undertook this research as an independent scholar. This is his first published article.